Diallo's Death
It wasn’t Amadou Diallo’s
fault that New York police officers shot him to death, but if he’d done
one thing differently, they would not have shot him.
A New York jury ruled that,
under New York law, it wasn’t the officers’ fault, either.
I have never been a police
officer, so I can only imagine the stress of confronting strangers of unknown
disposition day after day and night after night. Although police officers
are less likely to be killed on the job than airplane pilots, their level
and constancy of stress must be much higher than mine.
I’m neither excusing nor
blaming the officers for killing the unarmed man in the doorway of his
home. That’s not my job. I don’t understand why they were so on edge that
they thought Diallo’s wallet was a gun and poured 41 bullets into that
doorway, but that may be something only police officers can understand.
What made the difference
between a routine ID check and a shooting was that, when confronted by
the officers, Amadou Diallo did an unwise thing.
It was not a wrong thing
to reach for his wallet, presumably to show the officers his identification,
but it was unwise.
My father spent several
years as a civilian employee of a police department before I was born.
From the police stories he told me when I was a boy, one thing I’ve never
forgotten is what to do when stopped by a cop: Be still.
I once read some bad advice
from a psychologist who advised getting out of your car immediately and
going to the officer’s car before he can come to yours. The reasoning was
that the cop would be more comfortable dealing with you on his turf—at
his car. Bad idea.
We have no way of knowing
why a police officer pulls us over. It may be that a taillight is out,
or it may be that someone of our description and driving a similar car
just shot someone.
My father told me of a driver
who jumped out of his car and reached inside his coat. He wasn’t reaching
for a gun, but the police officer who’d pulled him over had every reason
to think he was, and he shot him.
Once when I was a teenager,
riding around with friends who’d had a few beers, we were having fun on
a long downhill in town making the car backfire through the exhaust. If
you turn off the key for a few seconds and let the engine pump unburned
gasoline into the exhaust system of older cars, when you turn the ignition
on again, the result is a satisfying blast. It sounds like a shotgun. We
did it several times.
When the lights came on
behind us and we pulled over, we assumed we’d been nabbed for coasting
too fast down the hill. The driver reached for the door handle. He was
going to go back to talk to the police because he was afraid they’d smell
beer if they came to the car.
I insisted he sit still
with his hands on top of the steering wheel and wait.
The officers ordered us
out, stood us against a bridge railing, and frisked us while others searched
the car. We were so concerned about beer, we didn’t understand why we were
being treated so roughly until they told us why we’d been stopped.
The officers weren’t interested
in speeding or beer. Someone had reported we were shooting. The cops were
looking for guns.
We explained the ignition
trick. I don’t remember whether the driver got a ticket, but I do remember
the chill I felt when I thought of what might have happened had he jumped
out and hurried back toward the police car.
Life would be less dangerous
for us and less stressful for police officers if we were all taught one
simple rule: When an officer stops you, be still. If you’re in a car, put
your hands where the officer can see them as he walks up to your window.
The officer will tell you when he wants you to reach for your wallet.
All other factors aside,
it’s too bad for him, and for the police officers who shot him, that Amadou
Diallo didn’t know that.
Back to main page
Back to archives
Next Article
|